Being already pretty upset by the thought of these dumb eyes, Carly's first thought is of course that the reason she's getting weird looks is...well.

Her eyes.

Eventually she'll snap to a near-tearful state at whichever fae were unfortunate enough to be giving her a look this time, and ask if there's somehow 'something' she's missed about these. She knows! They're super weird! It's terrible! Is there something they're going to say about it??